World Hypotheses

World Hypotheses

World Hypotheses: a study in evidence (AKA World Hypotheses: Prolegomena to systematic philosophy and a complete survey of metaphysics)is a book written by Stephen Pepper, published in 1942.

In World Hypotheses, Pepper demonstrates the error of Logical Positivism, that there is no such thing as data free from interpretation, and that root metaphors are necessary in epistemology. In other words, objectivity is a myth because there is no such thing as pure, objective fact. Consequently, an analysis is necessary to understand how to interpret these 'facts.' Pepper does so by developing the " [root metaphor method, ...] and outlines what he considers to be four basically adequate world hypotheses (world views or conceptual systems): formism, mechanism, contextualism, and organicism." He identifies the strengths and weaknesses of each of the world hypotheses as well as the paradoxical and sometimes mystifying effects of the effort to synthesize them. [ [http://people.sunyit.edu/~harrell/Pepper/Index.htm Index ] ]

Dogmatism

Pepper begins by demonstrating the very weak positions of utter skepticism and dogmatism while explaining that each are essentially two sides of the same coin. He has no problem with relative skepticism, where one suspends belief until justification is provided. But utter skepticism is essentially a dogmatist who doubts all things, always. Pepper defines a dogmatist "as one whose belief exceeds his cognitive grounds for belief." [Pepper, S.C., (1942). World Hypotheses: A study of evidence, University of California Press, Berkeley, Los Angeles and London.] If neither position of utter skepticism and dogmatism are cognitively justifiable, then knowledge about the world will be somewhere in between. Specifically, between Common Sense and Refined Knowledge.

Evidence

There is a tension between Common Sense and Refined Knowledge. Common sense is ubiquitous and ever present, and therefore gives a strong sense of certainty. But once you reflect upon common sense, it is no longer common sense and has moved into the realm of refined knowledge. To a large extent, the philosophy of science, and science in general, is interested in this shift.

Once you embark into refined knowledge, there are certain criteria as to what constitutes 'evidence.' In other words, there are rules governing how we know what we know (This should be recognized as an epistemological concept). And depending on the choice of your Root Metaphor (described below), different criteria exist as to what constitutes good evidence.

dubitanda

Pepper's jargon for Common Sense

data

Pepper's jargon for Multiplicative Corroboration, which simply refers to repeated empirical observation. If two people read a thermometer and agree on the reading, there has been Multiplicative Corroboration. In layman's terms, we call this data.

danda

Pepper's jargon for Structural Corroboration, which in layman's terms is similar to Logical Data.

Root Metaphors

Inadequate Root Metaphors

Mysticism

Animism

(Relatively) Adequate Root Metaphors

Formism

Mechanism

Contextualism

Organicism

References

Book review

Pepper, Stephen C. (1942). World hypotheses: A study in evidence. Berkeley: University of California Press. Reviewed in "JOURNAL OF THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF BEHAVIOR", 1988, 50, 97-111. [http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/picrender.fcgi?artid=1338844&blobtype=pdf link]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать реферат

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Hypotheses alternatives sur la responsabilite du VIH dans le SIDA — Hypothèses alternatives sur la responsabilité du VIH dans le sida Depuis 1984, différents mouvements pour la réévaluation du sida (AIDS reappraisal movement) ou mouvements dissidents du sida (AIDS dissident movement), également appelés de façon… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Hypothèses Alternatives Sur La Responsabilité Du VIH Dans Le SIDA — Depuis 1984, différents mouvements pour la réévaluation du sida (AIDS reappraisal movement) ou mouvements dissidents du sida (AIDS dissident movement), également appelés de façon péjorative mouvements négationnistes, plaident pour une… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Hypothèses alternatives sur la responsabilité du VIH dans le SIDA — Depuis 1984, différents mouvements pour la réévaluation du sida (AIDS reappraisal movement) ou mouvements dissidents du sida (AIDS dissident movement), également appelés de façon péjorative mouvements négationnistes, plaident pour une… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Hypothèses alternatives sur la responsabilité du VIH dans le sida — Depuis 1984, différents mouvements pour la réévaluation du sida (AIDS reappraisal movement) ou mouvements dissidents du sida (AIDS dissident movement), également appelés de façon péjorative mouvements négationnistes, plaident pour une… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Hypothèses alternatives sur la responsabilité du vih dans le sida — Depuis 1984, différents mouvements pour la réévaluation du sida (AIDS reappraisal movement) ou mouvements dissidents du sida (AIDS dissident movement), également appelés de façon péjorative mouvements négationnistes, plaident pour une… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • World Values Survey — Type Non profit association Founded 1981 Location …   Wikipedia

  • World Trade Center controlled demolition conspiracy theories — Aerial view of the debris field of the North Tower, 6 WTC, and 7 WTC (upper right) The World Trade Center controlled demolition conspiracy theory is a conspiracy theory which contends that the collapse of the World Trade Center was not caused by… …   Wikipedia

  • World view — A comprehensive world view (or worldview) is a term calqued from the German word Weltanschauung (Audio IPA|De Weltanschauung.ogg| [ˈvɛlt.ʔanˌʃaʊ.ʊŋ] ) Welt is the German word for world , and Anschauung is the German word for view or outlook. It… …   Wikipedia

  • Death and Adjustment Hypotheses — are a pair of multidimensional theories on the natural but neglected phenomenon of death [ Siddique, M.Z. (Accepted for publishing in 2008) Reviewing the phenomenon of death – a scientific effort from the Islamic world. Death Studies . Book… …   Wikipedia

  • Location hypotheses of Atlantis — Atlantis is the subject of a legend about an advanced island civilization that was destroyed or lost. The story of Atlantis was first mentioned around 360 B.C. in Plato s dialogues Timaeus and Critias , in which a character named Critias claims… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”